If you play dynasty fantasy football, you know how fast rookie value changes after Year 1. In this 2025 rookie re-draft, we looked at what we saw during the season and what we expect going forward, and re-drafted the class in a SuperFlex, Tight End Premium format.

This was a two-round mock with 24 rookies total — and the format matters a ton:

League Format (Scoring Settings)

• SuperFlex

• 6 points per passing TD

• Full PPR for non-TEs

• TE Premium: 1.75 PPR for tight ends

That scoring pushes quarterbacks up, and it makes elite tight ends feel like cheat codes.

2025 Rookie Re-Draft Results (Picks 1–24)

1.01 – Ashton Jeanty (RB)

Aaron kicked it “old school” with Jeanty at the 1.01 because bell-cow backs are hard to find — and Jeanty still profiles as a true volume back even in a tough Raiders situation. The theme here was simple: he didn’t lose the job, and opportunity still matters.

Dynasty take: Bell-cow workload keeps him elite, even if the team context isn’t perfect.

1.02 – Jaxson Dart (QB)

In SuperFlex, the value of a QB who can score through the air and on the ground is huge. Dart was framed as a smart vacuum pick (no team needs) because of his weekly ceiling — top 10 QB finishes and rushing utility. The group liked his future with strong coaching (Harbaugh) and upside if he stays healthy.

Dynasty take: SuperFlex QB with rushing = long-term value stability.

1.03 – Colston Loveland (TE)

Ethan leaned into the format and took Loveland as his TE3 in dynasty, even saying Loveland passed Tyler Warren for him down the stretch. The transcript highlighted Loveland’s late-season explosion, plus playoff usage and target volume — exactly what you want in TE Premium.

Dynasty take: TE Premium difference-maker; profiles like a receiver at TE.

1.04 – Omarion Hampton (RB)

Hampton stayed a top RB option for the group. The discussion focused on his Chargers fit, injuries on the line returning, and the coaching ecosystem. He flashed elite production before injuries and still has first-round investment and expected volume.

Dynasty take: Workhorse traits + team commitment = strong RB value.

1.05 – Tyler Warren (TE)

The commissioner went right back to tight end and grabbed Warren, calling him a “set it and forget it” TE in this format. The group agreed it’s hard not to take him in TE Premium after his rookie flashes.

Dynasty take: Elite positional advantage if the Colts QB situation improves.

1.06 – Tetairoa McMillan (WR)

McMillan was described as the clear alpha and best receiver in the class, with massive target volume and touchdown production. The panel emphasized his ceiling: perennial fantasy WR1 potential if Bryce Young continues developing.

Dynasty take: Alpha profile + target share = WR1 upside.

1.07 – RJ Harvey (RB)

Aaron went RB-heavy and planted his flag on RJ Harvey, comparing his role fit to a Kamara-type piece in Sean Payton’s offense and emphasizing “sneaky points” in PPR. The group debated this slot as slightly early, mostly due to committee concerns — but still viewed Harvey as a useful fantasy asset.

Dynasty take: PPR-friendly RB; value depends on Denver’s offseason moves.

1.08 – Harold Fannin Jr. (TE)

The commissioner leaned into TE Premium again, praising Fannin’s production despite a rough QB environment, plus multiple TE1 weekly finishes. There was also optimism tied to the coaching staff and the possibility of Njoku moving on.

Dynasty take: Volume + TE Premium scoring makes him a strong long-term play.

1.09 – Emeka Egbuka (WR)

Egbuka was framed as a player who flashed early, then cooled as the offense collapsed — but the group believes his role and opportunity return as key veterans age. The bet is on Year 2 growth and regaining dynasty momentum.

Dynasty take: Year 2 bounce-back candidate with strong long-term role.

1.10 – TreVeyon Henderson (RB)

Aaron took Henderson, noting the Patriots offense upside long-term and Henderson’s role stability despite Rhamondre being a factor. The group agreed Henderson showed enough mid-season explosiveness to justify top-12 value.

Dynasty take: High-upside RB, but watch usage trends early next season.

1.11 – Quinshon Judkins (RB)

The commissioner took Judkins right after Henderson — noting how these two stayed linked in rankings all year. The discussion emphasized workload ability, age, and optimism about his role when healthy.

Dynasty take: Young RB with volume profile = late first-round dynasty value.

1.12 – Cam Skattebo (RB)

Ethan closed Round 1 with Skattebo, projecting productivity in an improving New York offense and calling him a “man possessed” runner. The pick was framed as immediate-value oriented in a good direction offense.

Dynasty take: Shorter shelf-life risk, but strong near-term production upside.

ROUND 2

2.01 – Cam Ward (QB)

Aaron started Round 2 by grabbing a starting QB — the classic SuperFlex move. The transcript captured the tension: Ward hasn’t returned great ROI yet, but year-two coaching and weapons can change everything.

Dynasty take: High volatility QB; must show a leap early to keep long-term value.

2.02 – Tyler Shough (QB)

The commissioner took Shough, calling him a past SuperFlex value “steal” who produced down the stretch and offers rushing scores too. The panel generally preferred what Shough showed over Ward recently.

Dynasty take: Starting QB + rushing utility = strong SuperFlex leverage pick.

2.03 – Luther Burden III (WR)

Ethan made the case for Burden as a safe bet in an ascending Bears offense, citing how he became a go-to option and projecting him as a dependable WR2/3 type you can trust.

Dynasty take: Reliable weekly starter potential in a growing offense.

2.04 – Kyle Monangai (RB)

Aaron grabbed Monangai, pointing to trust usage in high-leverage situations and an expanding role at the expense of veterans.

Dynasty take: Role growth pick; could become a steady RB depth piece.

2.05 – Jayden Higgins (WR)

The commissioner selected Higgins as a Year 2 leap candidate, projecting him as the #2 behind Nico Collins and emphasizing that fixing the offensive line could unlock more consistent production.

Dynasty take: Buy-now profile; could grow into a dependable weekly flex.

2.06 – Oronde Gadsden II (TE)

Ethan went back to tight end, highlighting Gadsden’s spike weeks (20–30 point upside), flashes as a rookie, and belief that his role continues to ascend even with target competition.

Dynasty take: TE Premium upside swing with real weekly ceiling.

2.07 – Mason Taylor (TE)

Aaron stayed on the TE track, calling out Taylor’s target command and the hope that QB stability eventually supports the Jets offense. Even with jokes about the Jets, the pick was framed as a format-driven TE bet.

Dynasty take: TE Premium depth with role growth potential if QB play improves.

2.08 – Bhayshul Tuten (RB)

The commissioner took Tuten, explaining the long-term outlook: Houston’s RB room likely changes, but Jacksonville has opportunity (ETN leaving), giving Tuten a clearer runway to rise into 2026.

Dynasty take: Upside RB whose value could climb fast with opportunity.

2.09 – Travis Hunter (WR/CB)

Ethan took Hunter for upside, acknowledging the risk that he’s used more on defense — but not wanting to let the talent slide too far. The group agreed he’s a “don’t let him fall forever” type in this exercise.

Dynasty take: Boom/bust asset; value tied to offensive usage.

2.10 – Tre Harris (WR)

Aaron took Harris as a patience play, projecting a bigger role as veterans cycle out and the offense gets healthier. This was a “keep the faith” pick — not based on early season dominance, but on role expansion later.

Dynasty take: Better days ahead; watch offseason depth chart changes.

2.11 – Matthew Golden (WR)

The commissioner drafted Golden, pointing to the playoff flash, plus a depth chart opening (potential departures) creating a path to a Year 2 breakout. It was a bet on sophomore growth and opportunity.

Dynasty take: Late second-round upside WR; situation could open fast.

2.12 – Kaleb Johnson (RB)

Ethan finished the draft with a “fixer-upper” pick, betting on draft capital, college profile, and a chance to turn it around. Even with value falling, the argument was: if you’re taking a shot at 2.12, aim for the player most likely to regain value.

Dynasty take: Rebound stash; hold if the market won’t pay more than a 3rd.

Honorable Mentions (Just Missed the Top 24)

The show also discussed names who didn’t make the final 24: Shedeur Sanders, Woody Marks, Jacory Croskey-Merritt, Dylan Sampson, Jayden Blue, Tory Horton, Isaac TeSlaa, Kyle Williams, Pat Bryant, Chimere Dike, Terrence Ferguson, and even Quinn Ewers as a deeper watchlist QB.

Key Takeaways for 2025 Dynasty Rookie Drafts

• SuperFlex pushes QBs up, but only if they hold starting value.

• TE Premium makes elite tight ends worth reaching for — Loveland/Warren/Fannin/Gadsden all gained value in this format.

• A lot of this class is about Year 2 and Year 3 leaps, not instant league-winners.

• Patience wins: don’t panic sell the guys who need development time.